At a Fire Island Christmas reunion party, three guys recall their three versions of the events that happened at Cherry Grove the previous summer.
Larry Page
Ron Remena
John Carlo
Rick Johnson
Hugh Allen
Greg
Garry Hunt
Jeff Holt
Chris Michaels
Terry Caswell
Will Seagers
Leslie Vickers
Pepe Brazil
George's trick
George Sardi
Party host
David Littler
Frank Schmitt
Johnny Savoy
2018 · Movie
2004 · Movie
1959 · Movie
1987 · Movie
2001 · Movie
2009 · Movie
2021 · Movie
2012 · Movie
2023 · Movie
1981 · Movie
2024 · Movie
2019 · Movie
1998 · Movie
2015 · Movie
1984 · Movie
1990 · Movie
2008 · Movie
1988 · Movie